Alderac Entertainment Group (AEG) has been releasing expansion after expansion for the game Smash Up. Quickly, Smash Up is what is called a shuffle building game where players take 2 different factions shuffle them together to form their deck and they play competing for points by winning bases.
A couple of years ago, AEG released a storage solution called the Big Geeky Box that was large enough to hold the content that was released up until that point. It also included a bonus faction called The Geeks. But with the continual release of expansions, the Big Geeky Box has now become a bit too small, especially if using sleeved cards. Enter The Bigger Geekier Box.
The Bigger Geekier Box is the new storage solution that holds everything that has been released for Smash Up up to this point, including any promo factions.
By comparison the shape and dimensions of the boxes are completely different. The Big Geeky Box is a lot smaller and is a rectangular shape, whereas the Bigger Geekier Box is a large square-shaped box. The dimensions of the Bigger Geekier Box are 13″x13″x7″, having the same dimensions as Thunderstone Quest.
Inside the box there is a removable tray that has a separate tray to store all of the tokens.
Inside of the box there are 4 different rows to store the cards, opposed to 3 from the Big Geeky Box, complete with foam blocks to keep cards secure.
Also, there are dividers that come to separate each of the factions. The new dividers have the set name printed on them to make it easier for sorting the factions according to expansions as well.
There are also 2 factions that come with the Bigger Geekier Box: The Geeks for those who missed them from the Big Geeky Box and the Smash Up All Stars that is basically a best of set that was a foil pack that was given out at organized play events.
Finally, there is a comprehensive rulebook that comes with the box that has clarified rules, errata and card clarifications. There is also a section that describes how each faction operates and there is a cross-reference on the back page that makes it easier to get the appropriate bases to play with the factions in play.
WHERE DOES THIS HIT?
- More space for cards
- Dividers have sets printed on them
- Token organizer tray
- Comprehensive rulebook
- Includes Geeks and the Smash Up All Stars factions
WHERE DOES THIS MISS?
- No dividers for the Munchkin Smash Up set
- Takes up a lot of shelf space
- Costly investment for owners of the Big Geeky Box
THOUGHTS AND IMPRESSIONS
The Bigger Geekier Box is a useful accessory for Smash Up owners who are heavily invested in the game. The box certainly is bigger and it is geekier with the addition of a lot more faction artwork that graces the box. The quality of construction is good, but I found some of the foam blocks did not fit firmly in the card lanes, so they may not hold the cards securely. This may vary slightly from block to block. I also like the divider tray for the tokens, to separate the tokens from each set. I don’t find it necessary and the tray adds to the overall size of this box, which may be an issue for some people.
I like the new dividers. I like that the set name is printed on the lower part of the divider so users can identify what set each faction came from. The Sheep promo faction divider has improved coloring on it opposed to the original divider that was shipped with the faction cards. I found it a major oversight with the dividers in the fact that there were no new dividers included for the Munchkin Smash Up set. So I had to use the original dividers that came with the set, but they do not have the set name printed on them.
I like the fact that the Smash Up All Stars faction is included for people who may not have been able to get it from an organized play event. The inclusion of the Geeks faction is good for fans who did not get in on the Big Geeky Box, but it becomes a duplicate faction for owners of the Big Geeky Box.
The comprehensive rulebook is great. I like the errata and card clarifications that help straighten out any issues with card abilities. There is also a section that explains how each faction acts so players can know what to expect when playing them. The best part is that it eliminates having to hold on to multiple rule books.
I am not 100% sure where I stand with The Bigger Geekier Box. I think there are some cool things that the Bigger Geekier Box offers, but I already have the Big Geeky Box and have all of the expansions except for 2 of them. I am not sleeving the cards so I still have room, so to me this is not really necessary. So I am not saying this is a must buy accessory if you already own the Big Geeky Box; maybe if you sleeve your cards because this will give you that extra room.
There are things I like about the Bigger Geekier Box. From an aesthetics point of view, I love the new box with the artwork having LOTS more factions represented. I like the new dividers that have the set names printed on them. I also like the comprehensive rulebook that has the errata and card clarifications. I also like the cross-reference guide that makes sorting factions and grabbing bases for play easier. I appreciate the token tray, but I don’t find it necessary. Before, I just threw mine all in a ziplock baggie and that worked for me. The removable tray that has the token tray in it adds 2 1/2″ of depth to this box. To me this is 2 1/2″ of space that could have been saved.
I have one major issue with this box and it is its overall size. The original Big Geeky Box is 9″x14″x4 1/2″. The Bigger Geekier Box is 13″x13″x 7″. At this point, if you are not sleeving the cards, there is going to be a lot of wasted space, unless there are a LOT more expansions planned for Smash Up. With a 7″ depth on the box, this is a Kallax Killer. What I mean is that if you are using cube storage for your games, this one box takes up about the same space as 2 board games. If you own both the Bigger Geekier Box and Thunderstone Quest, the two games will not fit in the same cube.
A minor issue with this box is the fact that there were no dividers included for the Munchkin Smash Up set. I know that there were dividers included with Munchkin Smash Up, but they do not have the set name printed on them. All of the other sets for Smash Up had the upgraded dividers provided in the Bigger Geekier Box, so to me this is a bit of a miss for quality control.
I think that many owners of the Big Geeky Box are going to pass over this since they already invested in the original storage solution. With an MSRP of $40 that is a lot of money that would be invested in storage solutions, since the previous storage box would be pretty much obsolete.
If you are heavily invested in Smash Up and have not gotten a storage solution yet for Smash Up and you have a lot of extra shelf space, then I would say, yeah pick it up. It does a nice job of organizing the game with its growing expansion collection. If you are not sleeving your cards and already own the Big Geeky Box and have everything released up to this point, I think there is still enough room to hold several more expansions, so I can’t recommend it, Use the $40 to buy 2 more expansions for Smash Up as they are released.
I appreciate the effort from AEG to support Smash Up players with a storage solution that holds everything together. This Box is specifically aimed for those who are heavily invested in the game. Players who own the core set and maybe an expansion or 2 are better off with a 3rd party insert from either Go7 Gaming or The Broken Token.
Disclaimer: This copy of the Bigger Geekier Box was provided by Alderac Entertainment Group (AEG) for the purpose of review.